|
Books > Medicine > General issues > Medicolegal issues
The Oxford Handbook of Medical Ethics and Law is the definitive
guide to the legal and ethical issues around medical and surgical
practice. It is written with the busy clinician in mind who will
not have time to read lengthy and complex legal or philosophical
documents but requires the key information presented without
technical jargon in a handy quick-reference style. The handbook
also includes a substantial number of examples taken from a wide
variety of specialties with the relevant legal and ethical issues
clearly explained, so that the reader can see how these principles
play out in day-to-day patient care. Both medical students and
current professionals will find this an essential practical
resource.
An argument that the system of boards that license human-subject
research is so fundamentally misconceived that it inevitably does
more harm than good. Medical and social progress depend on research
with human subjects. When that research is done in institutions
getting federal money, it is regulated (often minutely) by
federally required and supervised bureaucracies called
"institutional review boards" (IRBs). Do-can-these IRBs do more
harm than good? In The Censor's Hand, Schneider addresses this
crucial but long-unasked question. Schneider answers the question
by consulting a critical but ignored experience-the law's learning
about regulation-and by amassing empirical evidence that is
scattered around many literatures. He concludes that IRBs were
fundamentally misconceived. Their usefulness to human subjects is
doubtful, but they clearly delay, distort, and deter research that
can save people's lives, soothe their suffering, and enhance their
welfare. IRBs demonstrably make decisions poorly. They cannot be
expected to make decisions well, for they lack the expertise,
ethical principles, legal rules, effective procedures, and
accountability essential to good regulation. And IRBs are censors
in the place censorship is most damaging-universities. In sum,
Schneider argues that IRBs are bad regulation that inescapably do
more harm than good. They were an irreparable mistake that should
be abandoned so that research can be conducted properly and
regulated sensibly.
U.S. military conflicts abroad have left nine million Americans
dependent on the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) for medical
care. Their "wounds of war" are treated by the largest hospital
system in the country-one that has come under fire from critics in
the White House, on Capitol Hill, and in the nation's media. In
Wounds of War, Suzanne Gordon draws on five years of observational
research to describe how the VHA does a better job than private
sector institutions offering primary and geriatric care, mental
health and home care services, and support for patients nearing the
end of life. In the unusual culture of solidarity between patients
and providers that the VHA has fostered, Gordon finds a working
model for higher-quality health care and a much-needed alternative
to the practice of for-profit medicine.
The work draws together a rich tapestry of material across many
different disciplines, covering the crucial relationship between
medicine and law from the early apothecaries to the modern-day
general practitioner. It presents an invaluable overview of the
subject and offers vital background reading to anyone interested in
medico-legal medicine, as well as providing a springboard for
students of medicine and law interested in researching the field
through its remarkable diversity of reference resources.
In "The Case against Assisted Suicide: For the Right to
End-of-Life Care," Dr. Kathleen Foley and Dr. Herbert Hendin
uncover why pleas for patient autonomy and compassion, often used
in favor of legalizing euthanasia, do not advance or protect the
rights of terminally ill patients. Incisive essays by authorities
in the fields of medicine, law, and bioethics draw on studies done
in the Netherlands, Oregon, and Australia by the editors and
contributors that show the dangers that legalization of assisted
suicide would pose to the most vulnerable patients. Thoughtful and
persuasive, this book urges the medical profession to improve
palliative care and develop a more humane response to the complex
issues facing those who are terminally ill.
Introduces key concepts and debates in health humanities and the
health professions. Keywords for Health Humanities provides a rich,
interdisciplinary vocabulary for the burgeoning field of health
humanities and, more broadly, for the study of medicine and health.
Sixty-five entries by leading international scholars examine
current practices, ideas, histories, and debates around health and
illness, revealing the social, cultural, and political factors that
structure health conditions and shape health outcomes. Presenting
possibilities for health justice and social change, this volume
exposes readers—from curious beginners to cultural analysts, from
medical students to health care practitioners of all fields—to
lively debates about the complexities of health and illness and
their ethical and political implications. A study of the vocabulary
that comprises and shapes a broad understanding of health and the
practices of healthcare, Keywords for Health Humanities guides
readers toward ways to communicate accurately and effectively while
engaging in creative analytical thinking about health and
healthcare in an increasingly complex world—one in which
seemingly straightforward beliefs and decisions about individual
and communal health represent increasingly contested terrain.
Mark Graber looks at the history of abortion law in action to argue
that the only defensible, constitutional approach to the issue is
to afford all women equal choice - abortion should remain legal or
bans should be strictly enforced. Steering away from metaphysical
critiques of privacy, Graber compares the philosophical,
constitutional, and democratic merits of the two systems of
abortion regulation witnessed in the twentieth-century: pre-Roe v.
Wade statutory prohibitions on abortion and Roe's ban on
significant state interference with the market for safe abortion
services. He demonstrates that before Roe, pro-life measures were
selectively and erratically administered, thereby subverting our
constitutional commitment to equal justice. Claiming that these
measures would be similarly administered if reinstated, the author
seeks to increase support for keeping abortion legal, even among
those who have reservations about its morality. Abortion should
remain legal, Graber argues, because statutory bans on abortion
have a history of being enforced in ways that intentionally
discriminate against poor persons and persons of color. In the
years before Roe, the same law enforcement officials who routinely
ignored and sometimes assisted those physicians seeking to
terminate pregnancies for their private patients too often
prevented competent abortionists from offering the same services to
the general public. This double standard violated the fundamental
human and constitutional right of equal justice under law, a right
that has powerful roots in the American political tradition and
that remains a major concern of the equal protection clause of the
Fourteenth Amendment.
Coercion is one of the most fascinating and controversial subjects
in psychiatry. It is a highly sensitive, and hotly debated topic in
which clinical practice, ethics, the law and public policy
converge. This book considers coercion within the healing and
ethical framework of therapeutic relationships and partnerships at
all levels, and addresses the universal problem of how to balance
safety versus autonomy when dealing with psychiatric treatment.
"Coercive Treatment in Psychiatry" is a much needed contribution
to the literature. The first three sections deal with the
conceptual and clinical aspects of coercive treatment, the legal
aspects and the ethical aspects of coercive treatment. In detail,
these sections cover a broad spectrum of issues: coercion in
institutions and in the community, coercive treatment and stigma,
the definition of best practice standards for coercive treatment,
de-escalation of risk situations, recent developments in mental
health legislation, mental health care and patients' rights,
cross-cultural perspectives on coercive treatment, historical
injustice in psychiatry, and paternalism in mental health. The
fourth section features users' views on coercive treatment: giving
voice to an often-unheeded population. Finally, the book addresses
the original topic of coercion and undue influence in decisions to
participate in psychiatric research.
This book presents the first comprehensive review of the issue
of coercion in psychiatry. With chapters written by the leading
experts in the field, many of whom are renowned as clear thinkers
and experienced clinicians, it may be seen as a starting point for
international discussions and initiatives in this field aiming to
minimize coercion.
Highly Commended in the Psychiatry section of the 2012 BMA Book
Awards.
The upheavals of the NHS reforms have caused a great deal of stress
and uncertainty in primary care, and professional development and
support for general practitioners needs to take account of this.
This book offers a group supervision model which can be used to
develop the core competencies needed for GPs to make the new
primary care organisations work. The book analyses how primary care
professionals have dealt with the various reforms of the past
decade, and picks apart the paralysing culture of politeness,
conflict avoidance and rivalry for power, to reveal how at the core
of reform is the struggle for each GP to construct a new
professional identity which integrates medicine, management and
politics.It proposes ways GPs can benefit from these experiences to
become equipped with the necessary competencies to be active
members or dynamic leaders in the new primary care organisations.
The doctor-patient relationship is no longer one-to-one, but
located within a group matrix, in the same way that a GP is now
required to work within a group framework. This book enables GPs to
develop the essential group skills they now need, and on which the
success of the healthcare reforms ultimately depends. 'A
challenging approach to understanding and supporting the
individuals who make up the primary care workforce. Gerhard Wilke
has drawn on his experiences to identify the reasons behind the
'dis-ease' felt by many practitioners, and to suggest models for
improving their morale. This book will be of interest to
practitioners working through the challenges of continuing 'top
down' reorganisation of the NHS and responding to the
reconfiguration of general practice partnerships into PCGs and
PCTs.'
As medical litigation continues to increase, the best defence for
doctors is to be aware of, and avoid, medical errors. This book
focuses on the key legal issues including medical documentation,
which reduce risk and liability when handled correctly. It contains
chapters on difficult patients and special issues for emergency
physicians. The case-based format demonstrates clinical relevance
and useful examples are drawn from office, hospital and community
settings. This book is the companion volume to Learning from
Medical Errors: Clinical Problems which focuses on the most common
clinical situations resulting in malpractice litigation. Learning
from Medical Errors: Legal Issues is vital reading for all doctors,
medical lecturers and teachers and medical lawyers.
Proposals have been put forward to replace the current paper
Medicare cards, which display beneficiaries Social Security
numbers, with electronically readable cards, and to issue
electronically readable cards to providers as well. Electronically
readable cards include cards with magnetic stripes and bar codes
and smart cards that can process data. Proponents of such cards
suggest that their use would bring a number of benefits to the
program and Medicare providers, including reducing fraud through
the authentication of beneficiary and provider identity at the
point of care, furthering electronic health information exchange,
and improving provider record keeping and reimbursement processes.
This book evaluates the different functions and features of
electronically readable cards; examines the potential benefits and
limitations associated with the use of electronically readable
cards in Medicare; examines the steps CMS and Medicare providers
would need to take to implement and use electronically readable
cards; and describes the lessons learned from the implementation
and use of electronically readable cards in other countries.
The primary aim of this book is to provide clear and concise
explanations about all aspects of the medico-legal process for
surgeons, other doctors and lawyers. A wide range of topics is
covered including: how the medico-legal arena is changing; the
legal principles involved; how to avoid medico-legal problems;
resolving complaints out of court; the surgeon as defendant; the
surgeon as expert; the GMC and the Coroner.
For decades, manufacturers from around the world relied on asbestos
from the town of Asbestos, Quebec, to produce fire-retardant
products. Then, over time, people learned about the mineral's
devastating effects on human health. Dependent on this deadly
industry for their community's survival, the residents of Asbestos
developed a unique, place-based understanding of their local
environment; the risks they faced living next to the giant opencast
mine; and their place within the global resource trade. This book
unearths the local-global tensions that defined Asbestos's proud
and painful history to reveal the challenges similar resource
communities have faced - and continue to face today.
Mary Seacole: The Making of the Myth is the first book to challenge
the popular misconceptions that surround Mary Seacole s iconic
status as a pioneer nurse and battlefield heroine, intended, by
some, to replace Florence Nightingale in those roles. McDonald
masterfully disentangles reality from the myths, both those that
exaggerate Seacole s work and ignore or denigrate Nightingale s.
Drawing on the considerable primary sources available on both
women, including letters and journal notes by officers, medical
doctors and other observers during the Crimean War, as well as
Seacole s own memoir, McDonald debunks claims that Seacole was the
real heroine of the Crimean War and a pioneer of healthcare. Her
book supports the recognition of Seacole for her life and work, but
not as the decorated battlefield heroine as she is typically
portrayed today."
This easy-to-read book explains the nuts and bolts of the Mental
Capacity Act 2005 that clinicians need to understand and use in
their daily practice. This Act now gives all clinicians the
authority to provide medical care and treatment for people over 16
years of age who lack the capacity to consent for themselves. It
covers: how to assess whether a person lacks capacity and how to
clarify the threshold of decision-making incapacity; the range,
scope and limitations of the various authorities to treat
(including 'best interests' decisions, advance decisions and
lasting powers of attorney); the range of safeguards in place (such
as the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLs), the Court of
Protection and Independent Mental Health Advocates); and relevant
aspects of the Human Rights Act 1998, the Mental Health Act
(including all recent amendments) and illustrative case law. There
have been numerous developments in case law in the two years since
the first edition. The second edition expands on clinically
relevant issues from the courts, and assists in bridging the gap
between court judgments and the frontline clinician.
In the 1800s, opium and cocaine could be easily obtained to treat a
range of ailments. Drug dependency, when it occurred, was
considered a matter of personal vice. Near the end of the century,
attitudes shifted and access to drugs became more restricted. Dan
Malleck reveals how different forces converged in the early 1900s
to influence lawmakers and set the course for the drug laws that
exist today. As this book shows, social concerns about drug
addiction had less to do with the long pipe and shadowy den than
with lobbying by medical professionals, concern about the morality
and future of the nation, and a burgeoning pharmaceutical industry.
Dementia is a topic of enormous human, medical, economic, legal and
ethical importance. Its importance grows as more of us live longer.
The legal and ethical problems it raises are complex, intertwined
and under-discussed. This book brings together contributions from
clinicians, lawyers and ethicists - all of them world leaders in
the field of dementia - and is a comprehensive, scholarly yet
accessible library of all the main (and many of the fringe)
perspectives. It begins with the medical facts: what is dementia?
Who gets it? What are the current and future therapeutic and
palliative options? What are the main challenges for medical and
nursing care? The story is then taken up by the ethicists, who
grapple with questions such as: is it legitimate to lie to dementia
patients if that is a kind thing to do? Who is the person whose
memory, preferences and personality have all been transformed by
their disease? Should any constraints be placed on the sexual
activity of patients? Are GPS tracking devices an unpardonable
interference with the patient's freedom? These issues, and many
more, are then examined through legal lenses. The book closes with
accounts from dementia sufferers and their carers. It is the first
and only book of its kind, and the authoritative text.
Reproductive donation is the most contentious area of assisted
reproduction. Even within Europe there are wide variations in what
is permitted in each country. This multi-disciplinary book takes a
fresh look at the practices of egg, sperm and embryo donation and
surrogacy, bringing together ethical analysis and empirical
research. New evidence is offered on aspects of assisted
reproduction and the families these create, including
non-traditional types. One of the key issues addressed is should
children be told of their donor origin? If they do learn the
identity of their donor, what kinds of relationships may be forged
between families, the donor and other donor sibling families?
Should donation involve a gift relationship? Is intra-familial
donation too close for comfort? How should we understand the
growing trend for 'reproductive tourism'? This lively and informed
discussion offers new insights into reproductive donation and the
resulting donor families.
What are the moral challenges that confront doctors as they manage
healthcare institutions? How do we build trust in medical
organisations? How do we conceptualize moral action? Based on
accounts given by senior doctors from organisations throughout the
UK, this book discusses the issues medical leaders find most
troubling and identifies the moral tensions they face. Moral
Leadership in Medicine examines in detail how doctors protect
patients' interests, implement morally controversial change, manage
colleagues in difficulty and rebuild trust after serious medical
harm. The book discusses how leaders develop moral narratives to
make sense of these situations, how they behave while balancing
conflicting moral goals and how they influence those around them to
do the right thing in difficult circumstances. Based on empirical
ethical analysis, this volume is essential reading for clinicians
in leadership roles and students and academics in the fields of
healthcare management, medical law and healthcare ethics.
|
|