Relief at catching a flight fades as Abigail Forrester recognizes her seatmate as Doctor Nicholas Creighton, her ex-fiance. When a storm grounds the plane, she must depend on Nick to get her home in time for the Christmas Eve gathering at Granny Forrester's. Will bad weather, snow covered roads, and a car accident melt Abby's frozen heart enough to see that her true Christmas wish is sitting right beside her?

Ashley O'Neil receives an email from a stranger asking her for a date, thanks to a meddlesome friend who filled out an application with an online dating service on Ashley's behalf. She agrees to meet Marc Chandler, at a local restaurant and finds herself attracted to the man. Unbeknownst to Ashley, Marc is an undercover agent with the FBI. He's in Medford, Oregon to investigate a diamond smuggling ring. The FBI suspects the diamonds may be entering the country inside packages being delivered to Ashley's doll shop. In spite of his determination not to get involved with Ashley, Marc loses his heart as he tries to determine if she's innocent, or right in the middle of this crime.

Annie Benson, widowed and seven months pregnant with twins, is convinced God doesn't waste time on unimportant people like her. She's working as a waitress in a little California town when she receives word she's inherited a small ranch in Wyoming. Excited and relieved, Annie wants to spend Christmas in her new home. As she exits the bus, a very handsome man offers her a hand. He is the local doctor and her new neighbor, Gabriel St. Nick. While stuck in a snowstorm and in labor, can Gabe convince Annie that God loves her and so does he?