|
Books > Humanities > Religion & beliefs > General > Comparative religion
It is often assumed that religion is the backward-looking servant
of tradition and the status quo, utterly opposed to the new. This
refrain in so much of recent polemical writing has permeated the
public mind and can even be found in academic publications. But
recent scholarship increasingly shows that this view is a gross
simplification - that, in fact, religious beliefs and practices
have contributed to significant changes in human affairs: political
and legal, social and artistic, scientific and commercial. This is
certainly not to say that religion is always innovative. But the
relationship between religion and innovation is much more complex
and instructive than is generally assumed. Religion and Innovation
includes contributions from leading historians, archaeologists, and
social scientists, who offer findings about the relationship
between religion and innovation. The essays collected in this
volume range from discussions of the transformative power of
religion in early societies; to re-examinations of our notions of
naturalism, secularization, and progress; to explorations of
cutting-edge contemporary issues. Combining scholarly rigor with
clear, accessible writing, Religion and Innovation: Antagonists or
Partners? is essential reading for anyone interested in the history
of religion and the ongoing debates about its role in the modern
world and into the future.
In theological discourse, argues Hugh Nicholson, the political goes
"all the way down." One never reaches a bedrock level of
politically neutral religious facts, because all theological
discourse - even the most sublime, edifying, and "spiritual"--is
shot through with polemical elements.
Liberal theologies, from the Christian fulfillment theology of the
nineteenth century to the pluralist theology of the twentieth, have
assumed that religious writings attain spiritual truth and
sublimity despite any polemical elements they might contain.
Through his analysis and comparison of the Christian mystical
theologian Meister Eckhart and his Hindu counterpart IaSkara,
Nicholson arrives at a very different conclusion. Polemical
elements may in fact constitute the creative source of the
expressive power of religious discourses. Wayne Proudfoot has
argued that mystical discourses embody a set of rules that repel
any determinate understanding of the ineffable object or experience
they purport to describe. In Comparative Theology and the Problem
of Religious Rivalry, Nicholson suggests that this principle of
negation is connected, perhaps through a process of abstraction and
sublimation, with the need to distinguish oneself from one's intra-
and/or inter-religious adversaries.
Nicholson proposes a new model of comparative theology that
recognizes and confronts one of the most urgent cultural and
political issues of our time: namely, the "return of the political"
in the form of anti-secular and fundamentalist movements around the
world. This model acknowledges the ineradicable nature of an
oppositional dimension of religious discourse, while honoring and
even advancing the liberal project of curtailing intolerance and
prejudice in the sphere of religion."
The ambiguity concerning the interpretation of the 'physical body'
in religious thought is not peculiar to any given religion, but is
discernible in the scriptures, practices, and disciplines in most
of the world's major religious traditions. This book seeks to
address the nuances of difference within and between religious
traditions in the treatment and understanding of what constitutes
the body as a carrier of religious meaning and/or vindication of
doctrine. Bringing together an international team of contributors
from different disciplines, this collection addresses the
intersection of religion, gender, corporeality and/or sexuality in
various Western and Eastern cultures. The book analyses instances
when religious meaning is attributed to the human body's
physicality and its mechanics in contrast to imagined or
metaphorical bodies. In other cases, it is shown that the body may
function either as a vehicle or a hindrance for mystical knowledge.
The chapters are arranged chronologically and across religious
orientations, to offer a differentiated view on the body from a
global perspective. This collection is an exciting exploration of
religion and the human body. As such, it will be of great interest
to scholars in religious studies, theology, Islamic studies, South
Asian studies, history of religions and gender studies.
As globalization proceeds at an ever increasing and more
unrelenting pace, relations among the world's religions are taking
on both a new visibility and a new urgency. Christian theologians
and others intent on innovative formulations in the theology of
religions are making interreligious dialogue with non-Christians a
priority. One way to promote creative scholarship in this quest is
to tap into interdisciplinary resources, and the author of this
volume is uniquely qualified to do so since he holds graduate
degrees in both theology and cultural anthropology. Aaron Thomas
Raverty's Refuge in Crestone: A Sanctuary for Interreligious
Dialogue elucidates how the praxis of interreligious dialogue, as
outlined in key Vatican documents in the Catholic Church, could be
better served by attending to the qualitative ethnographic methods
of sociocultural anthropology. Because the material, behavioral,
and cognitive aspects of dialogue-as revealed in daily life, common
social and political action, religious experience, and theological
exchange-are embedded in culture, they are amenable to ethnographic
analysis. Using the unique, multi-religious Colorado site of
Crestone and its environs as a fieldwork "laboratory" and
self-described "Refuge for World Truths," the ethnographic data
gleaned from this project exemplify the creative interdisciplinary
contributions of anthropology to theologizing. It seeks to
demonstrate, using an empirical, multi-religious community as its
focus, how anthropology can support interreligious dialogue. The
results of such dialogue could not only assist the scholarly
community by helping theologians arrive at new formulations in the
burgeoning area of the theology of religions, but might also serve
the more practical goal of promoting peace-as an alternative to
violence-in today's complex and sorely troubled world.
Traditionally, university students have gained access to world
religions by reading primary texts. Discovering World Religions at
24 Frames Per Second takes students beyond the written page,
offering an exploration of the same religious traditions through
the study of feature films. The many definitions of religion are
examined along with its various components, including doctrine,
myth, ethics, ritual, and symbol. Specific religious traditions,
including Hinduism, Sikhism, Zoroastrianism, Buddhism,
Confucianism, Daoism, popular religion, and Shinto are examined.
Biographical sketches of directors whose films tend to focus on a
particular religious tradition are also included, such as Zhang
Yimou, Hayao Miyazaki, Deepa Mehta, and Akira Kurosawa. Discovering
World Religions at 24 Frames Per Second is unique in the area of
religion and film studies in that it isn't just a collection of
essays. Instead it provides the introductory student with the
necessary background information on the various religions before
looking at how their ideas can be understood not through texts but
through the cinematic medium. To keep the conversation fresh, most
of the films used in the book were made within the last decade.
Furthermore, examples range from popular, mainstream fare, such as
Star Wars and the Lord of the Rings trilogy to lesser-known foreign
films, such as The Wooden Man's Bride and The Great Yokai War.
Several films with a "cult-like" following are also discussed,
including Fight Club, Princess Mononoke, Spirited Away, and Jacob's
Ladder. This book is also unique in that instead of drawing upon
the Judeo-Christian tradition, it draws from Eastern traditions.
On San Marcos Avenue in St. Augustine, Florida, stands the
replicated Mission Nombre de Dios. Towering over the mission is a
208-foot stainless steel cross marking the site of the first known
Catholic mass celebrated in Florida in 1620. A few hundred miles to
the north in Montgomery, Alabama, sits the Dexter Avenue Baptist
Church, known to many as the birthplace of the civil rights
movement. Newport, Rhode Island's Touro Synagogue, dedicated in
1763, urged new leaders Washington and Jefferson to form a
government ""which to bigotry gives no sanction, to persecution no
assistance."" From the pre-Columbian Anasazi kivas of Colorado
built in the 1300s to the Peace Chapel constructed in 1970 on the
Canadian border, this work examines the roots of 51 historic sites
throughout the United States. Each entry provides detailed
background material on the place of worship and those who
established it, along with its location and religious affiliation.
Sites include those devoted to Indian or Native American, Muslim,
Jewish, Buddhist, Catholic, Protestant, Mormon, Baha'i, and other
beliefs. The essays also place the church or site into an
historical perspective, tracing how their foundings impacted the
development of the United States.
Often ignored, misunderstood, or compared with Christian belief in
a haphazard or inconsistent manner, the Mysteries of the
Graeco-Roman world, when handled carefully and consistently, can
aid in elucidating the context of New Testament texts. By closely
examining the Eleusinian Mysteries and the Mysteries of Isis, and
particularly their promises of a pleasant afterlife in Hades for
those initiated into the cults, this work offers insight into
difficult interpretational issues in First Corinthians 15. The work
proceeds from a methodological commitment to understanding the
Mysteries in their own right and without an overlay of Christian
belief. The book includes a broad overview of the Eleusinian
Mysteries and the Mysteries of Isis and their place in Graeco-Roman
culture, taking a deep and careful dive into conceptions of the
afterlife in these cults. In each instance available historical
data is considered, from works of mythology to dramas to
archeological fragments, all with a focus on afterlife beliefs.
With an ultimate goal to better understand Paul's writing in First
Corinthians 15, the study includes an overview of Corinthian
society and a particular examination of the available evidence
concerning the impact of the Mysteries on Corinthians' expectation
of the afterlife. Having considered the Mysteries independently,
the work turns to First Corinthians 15 with a brief exegetical
overview before drawing careful comparisons between Paul's teaching
and the afterlife beliefs of the Mysteries. The book concludes with
suggestions for interpretational issues on Paul's teaching in first
Corinthians 15 regarding death and resurrection and baptism for the
dead.
Theologians have had to increasingly engage with beliefs and
practises outside of their own traditions. The resultant "theology
of religions" is, however, often formulated in isolation from the
religions they are describing. This book provides a comparison of
the development of theology of religions in Western Christianity
and its application in anIslamic context. It also shows the
parallels between some specific forms of theology of religions,
i.e. exclusivism, inclusivism or pluralism, in both Islamic and
Christian traditions. The arguments of Christian and Muslim
theologians, including the specific contributions of Rowan Williams
and Jerusha Lamptey, are examined in order to reveal the
interconnections and contradictions of their pluralist, exclusivist
and inclusivist approaches. This provides a rounded picture of
Christian-Muslim understanding of religious others and prepares the
ground for a stronger and more sophisticated Islamic theology of
religions. This is vital reading for those studying theology of
religions, comparative theology and interfaith relations.
This book explores the idea of religious pluralism while defending
the norms of secular cosmopolitanism, which include liberty,
tolerance, civility, and hospitality. The secular cosmopolitan
ideal requires us to be more tolerant and more hospitable toward
religious believers and non-believers from diverse traditions in
our religiously pluralistic world. Some have argued that the
world's religions can be united around a common core. This book
argues that it is both impossible and inadvisable either to reduce
religion to one thing or to deny religion. Instead, the book
affirms non reductive pluralism and seeks to understand how we
should live in a pluralistic world. Building on work in the
sociology of religion and philosophy of religion, the book examines
the grown of religious diversity (and the spread of nonreligion) in
the contemporary world. It argues that religious toleration,
hospitality, and compassion must be extended in a global direction.
Secular cosmopolitanism recognizes that each person has a right to
his or her deepest beliefs and that the diversity of the world's
religious and non-religious traditions cannot be reduced or
eliminated.
The book offers a comprehensive discussion on the Buddhist
liberation and meditation concepts based on the original Pali
scriptures of Theravada Buddhism. It interprets the early Buddhist
soteriology critically and sympathetically by interweaving the
Buddhological and the Buddhistic debates on understanding the
Buddha's original teaching on bondage, liberation, liberated ones,
and meditation. It showcases the liberal and pluralistic character
of early Buddhist soteriology by interpreting it psychologically
through the lens of the Buddha's recognition of two sets of
psychosomatic and epistemic mental configurations active in the
human mind. It shows how this dualism pervades the early Buddhist
soteriology by pointing out its recognition of craving and
ignorance as two causes of suffering; the emancipation of mind and
the emancipation by wisdom as two constituents of liberation; and
the meditative appeasing and the meditative watching as two methods
to attain that liberation. It demonstrates how the Buddha
structures a gradual path to liberation enabling individuals to
experience many temporary and irreversible secondary goals along
the way and allowing them to join the path at any stage appropriate
to their temperaments and advancement at a given time and space.
The book therefore serves the students and scholars of Buddhism,
religion, and psychology to obtain a comprehensive and insightful
introduction to Buddhist soteriology.
Down to Earth scientifically describes the multitude of
environmental problems besetting planet earth and indicates why
these environmental problems are, at their root, a spiritual or
religious challenge. Simply learning about the scientific
description of these environmental threats will not be sufficient
to solve them, the author argues, for attitudes must be changed and
behavioral patterns must be altered. This need for change
invariably confronts the core values that we hold and the routine
actions that we undertake. Through an examination of the worldviews
and sacred texts of eight spiritual traditions, we learn of the
common insights and powerful resources that these world religions
can offer. The author believes that it is necessary to join an
ecological conscience to an ecological consciousness for humans to
exercise custodianship of nature both responsibly and sustainably.
When Muslim and Christian scholars met in 2001 in Samsun, Turkey
for a symposium on inter-religious dialogue as a contribution to
world peace, little did they know that September 11th was less than
three months away. The events of that tragic day underline the
urgency of such dialogue. As conflicts surfaced in Afghanistan,
Palestine/Israel, Kashmir, Pakistan, Chechnya, and Iraq, the need
to understand the underlying issues of the conflict became evident.
The papers found in found in Muslim and Christian Reflections on
Peace explore how people of diverse faiths can communicate, dispite
discord, on issues of truth and justice. These Christian and Muslim
reflections from the symposium in Turkey, which straddles East and
West, are an attempt to explore some of these issues.
Thinking about ultimate reality is becoming increasingly
transreligious. This transreligious turn follows inevitably from
the discovery of divine truths in multiple traditions. Global
communications bring the full range of religious ideas and
practices to anyone with access to the internet. Moreover, the
growth of the "nones" and those who describe themselves as
"spiritual but not religious" creates a pressing need for
theological thinking not bound by prescribed doctrines and fixed
rituals. This book responds to this vital need. The chapters in
this volume each examine the claim that if the aim of theology is
to know and articulate all we can about the divine reality, and if
revelations, enlightenments, and insights into that reality are not
limited to a single tradition, then what is called for is a
theology without confessional restrictions. In other words, a
Theology Without Walls. To ground the project in examples, the
volume provides emerging models of transreligious inquiry. It also
includes sympathetic critics who raise valid concerns that such a
theology must face. This is a book that will be of urgent interest
to theologians, religious studies scholars, and philosophers of
religion. It will be especially suitable for those interested in
comparative theology, inter-religious and interfaith understanding,
new trends in constructive theology, normative religious studies,
and global philosophy of religion.
|
|