|
|
Books > Philosophy > Western philosophy > Modern Western philosophy, c 1600 to the present > General
Scottish philosopher Lady Mary Shepherd (1777-1847) wrote two books
that she conceived as one unified project: Essay Upon the Relation
of Cause and Effect (1824) and Essays on the Perception of an
External Universe (1827). While they were well received in her day,
Shepherd's insightful philosophical writings have been neglected
for some 150 years and are only now receiving the scholarly
attention they deserve. Mary Shepherd: A Guide by Deborah Boyle,
part of the Oxford Guides to Philosophy series, navigates students
of philosophy or general readers through Shepherd's two significant
works. The first four chapters address topics raised in the 1824
Essay: Shepherd's arguments for two key causal principles, her
objections to Hume and her alternative accounts of causation and
causal inference; her theory of objects as bundles of qualities;
her critique of Thomas Brown's defence of Humean causation; and her
discussion of London surgeon William Lawrence's accounts of
sentience and life, which Shepherd treats as a case study of how
Humean theory can lead to errors in scientific reasoning. Chapter 5
covers topics central to both of Shepherd's books: what she means
by "sensation," "idea," "will," "imagination," "understanding,"
"reasoning," and "latent reasoning." The remaining five chapters
proceed systematically through Shepherd's 1827 book, where she
seeks to prove, against Berkeleian idealism, that we can know that
an external world of mind-independent matter exists. Boyle
discusses Shepherd's proofs for such an external world, her
responses to various sceptical challenges, and her specific
objections to Berkeley. Each chapter ends with a list of works for
further reading and a glossary of terms that explain Shepherd's
sometimes idiosyncratic philosophical vocabulary, resulting in an
essential guide to a philosopher who exerted considerable influence
during her time.
Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason is a key element of
the system of philosophy which Kant introduced with his Critique of
Pure Reason, and a work of major importance in the history of
Western religious thought. It represents a great philosopher's
attempt to spell out the form and content of a type of religion
that would be grounded in moral reason and would meet the needs of
ethical life. It includes sharply critical and boldly constructive
discussions on topics not often treated by philosophers, including
such traditional theological concepts as original sin and the
salvation or 'justification' of a sinner, and the idea of the
proper role of a church. This new edition includes slightly revised
translations, a revised introduction with expanded discussion of
certain key themes in the work, and up-to-date guidance on further
reading.
The papers published here were given at the second biennial
conference of the Hegel Society of America, held at the University
of Notre Dame, November 9-11, 1972. They appear in an order which
reflects roughly two headings: (1) Hegel's conception of the
history of philosophy in general, and (2) his relation to
individual thinkers both before and after him. Given the importance
of the history of philosophy for Hegel, and the far-reaching impact
of his thought upon subsequent philosophy, it becomes immediately
apparent that we have here only a beginning. At the conference,
cries went up "Why not Hegel and Aristotle, Aquinas, HusserI and
Hart mann?" Indeed, why not? The answer, of course, might be given
by Hegel himself: if we wish to accomplish anything, we have to
limit ourselves. We trust that future conferences and scholarship
will bring to light these relationships and the many more which
testify to Hegel's profound presence in the mainstream of past and
present thought. It is furthermore no accident that the renaissance
of Hegelian studies has brought with it a rebirth of the history of
philosophy as something relevant to our own problems. For Hegel,
the object of philosophy is alone the truth, the history of
philosophy is philosophy itself, and this truth which it gives us
cannot be what has passed away."
An important figure in the natural law tradition and in the
Scottish Enlightenment, Gershom Carmichael defended a strong theory
of rights and drew attention to Grotius, Pufendorf, and Locke.
Gershom Carmichael was a teacher and writer who played an important
role in the Scottish Enlightenment of the eighteenth century. His
philosophy focused on the natural rights of individuals--the
natural right to defend oneself, to own the property on which
one
has labored, and to services contracted for with others. Carmichael
argued that slavery is incompatible with the rights of men and
citizens, and he believed that subjects have the right to resist
rulers who exceed the limits of their powers.
Although he appealed to the authority of Grotius and Locke, the
grounds on which he defended natural rights were distinctively his
own. He drew upon the Reformed or Presbyterian theology to propose
that, in respecting the natural rights of individuals, one shows
one's reverence for God's creation. Inasmuch as all of mankind
longs for lasting happiness, which can be found only in worship of
or reverence for God, such reverence is the natural law which
obliges all to respect the rights of all.
"Natural Rights" includes "Supplements and Observations on
Pufendorf" (1724), "Natural Theology" (1729), "Logic" (1722), two
theses, and a manuscript on teaching, all in English for the first
time.
Gershom Carmichael (1672-1729) was the first professor of moral
philosophy at the University of Glasgow, preceding Hutcheson,
Smith, and Reid.
James Moore is Professor of Political Science at Concordia
University in Montreal.
Michael Silverthorne is Honorary University Fellow in the School of
Classics at the University of Exeter.
Knud Haakonssen is Professor of Intellectual History and Director
of the Centre for Intellectual History at the University of Sussex,
England.
This innovative monograph is of major significance for not only
students and academics undertaking research on the history of
Mexico during the long dictatorship of Porfirio Diaz, but also
scholars specializing in the history of ideas, philosophy and
science. Unlike previous discussions of positivism in Latin
America, this book presents a detailed analysis of the English
thinker, Herbert Spencer's original works as a necessary gateway
into the discussion of the thinking of 'The Scientists'. Its
principal purpose is to revisit the influential thesis of Leopoldo
Zea which proposed that 'The Scientists' throughout this period
were Spencerian positivists. This book offers a revisionist
analysis of the original papers of 'The Scientists', Francisco
Bulnes and Justo Sierra, as well as their political and
philosophical ideas and activities. This analysis demonstrates that
their eclectic discourses used the ideas of the American Social
Darwinists, and those from Spencer, Darwin, August Comte, and other
European writers, concluding that 'The Scientists' lacked a clear
leader and had an ambivalent relationship with Diaz. It interprets
'The Scientists' not as 'heroes' or 'villains', but as men
struggling to appropriate European philosophical advances into
their quest to modernise Mexico.
The present volume represents the proceedings of the Marquette
Hegel Symposium, held at Marquette University, Milwaukee,
Wisconsin, on June 2-5, 1970. The Symposium, celebrating the
two-hundredth annivers ary of Hegel's birth, was presented under
the combined sponsorship of the Philosophy Department of Marquette
University, the American Coun cil of Learned Societies, and the
Johnson Foundation of Racine, Wiscon sin. Its general theme
embraced not only specific topics of interest in con temporary
Hegel studies, but also the wider aspects of the influences and
impact of Hegel's thought upon contemporary philosophical,
political, and social problems. Principal contributors and
panelists were selected for their scholarly achievements in Hegel
studies and also in keeping with the broad view of the Hegelian
legacy in current thought. All sessions of the Symposium were
plenary, and designed for maximum discussion and in terchange among
participants. The Symposium Committee regrets that it has not been
feasible to incorporate the transcript of the discussions (ex cept
for the round-table discussion on editing and translating Hegel)
into this volume. The papers presented in each day's sessions are
published here with editorial changes and corrections made by their
respective authors. The papers by Professors Otto Poggeler and Eric
Weil were originally trans lated by members of our Committee: the
present versions incorporate many changes and corrections made by
their authors. The comments on each paper were brought into their
present form only after the Symposium, and in the light of the
discussions which took place during it."
The present study seeks to treat in depth a relatively restricted
portion of Hegel's thought but one that has not yet received
intensive treatment by Hegel scholars in English. In the Hegelian
system of philosophical sciences, the Anthropology directly follows
the Philosophy of Nature and forms the first of the three sciences
of Subjective Spirit: 1 Anthropo logy, Phenomenology, and
Psychology. The section on Subjective Spirit is then followed by
sections on Objective Spirit and Absolute Spirit. The three
sections together comprise the Philosophy of Spirit (Philosophie
des Geistes 2), which constitutes the third and concluding main
division of Hegel's total system as presented in the Encyclopedia
of Philosophic Sciences in Outline. a Hegel intended to write a
separate full-scale work on the philosophy of Subjective Spirit as
he had done on Objective Spirit (the Philosophy of Right), but died
before he could do so. . Thus the focus of our study is quite
concentrated. Its relatively narrow scope within the vast compass
of the Hegelian system may be justified, 1 Iring Fetscher (HegeUt
Lehre vom Menschen, Stuttgart, 1970, p. 11) notes the lack of a
modem commentary to Hegel's Encyclopedia, and in particular to the
section on Subjective Spirit. Brief accounts of this section in
English may be found in: Hugh A. Reyburn, The Ethical Theory of
Hegel (Oxford, 1921), Chapter V; and O. R. O. Mure, A Study of
Hegers Logic (Oxford, 1950), pp. 2-22."
"Hume's Politics" provides a comprehensive examination of David
Hume's political theory, and is the first book to focus on Hume's
monumental "History of England" as the key to his distinctly
political ideas. Andrew Sabl argues that conventions of authority
are the main building blocks of Humean politics, and explores how
the "History" addresses political change and disequilibrium through
a dynamic treatment of coordination problems. Dynamic coordination,
as employed in Hume's work, explains how conventions of political
authority arise, change, adapt to new social and economic
conditions, improve or decay, and die. Sabl shows how Humean
constitutional conservatism need not hinder--and may in fact
facilitate--change and improvement in economic, social, and
cultural life. He also identifies how Humean liberalism can offer a
systematic alternative to neo-Kantian approaches to politics and
liberal theory.
At once scholarly and accessibly written, "Hume's Politics"
builds bridges between political theory and political science. It
treats issues of concern to both fields, including the prehistory
of political coordination, the obstacles that must be overcome in
order for citizens to see themselves as sharing common political
interests, the close and counterintuitive relationship between
governmental authority and civic allegiance, the strategic ethics
of political crisis and constitutional change, and the ways in
which the biases and injustices endemic to executive power can be
corrected by legislative contestation and debate.
This volume brings together essential writings by the unjustly
neglected nineteenth-century philosopher Frances Power Cobbe
(1822-1904). A prominent ethicist, feminist, champion of animal
welfare, and critic of Darwinism and atheism, Cobbe was well known
and highly regarded in the Victorian era. This collection of her
work introduces contemporary readers to Cobbe and shows how her
thought developed over time, beginning in 1855 with her Essay on
Intuitive Morals, in which she set out her duty-based moral theory,
arguing that morality and religion are indissolubly connected. This
work provided the framework within which she addressed many
theoretical and practical issues in her prolific publishing career.
In the 1860s and early 1870s, she gave an account of human duties
to animals; articulated a duty-based form of feminism; defended a
unique type of dualism in the philosophy of mind; and argued
against evolutionary ethics. Cobbe put her philosophical views into
practice, campaigning for women's rights and for first the
regulation and later the abolition of vivisection. In turn her
political experiences led her to revise her ethical theory. From
the 1870s onwards she increasingly emphasized the moral role of the
emotions, especially sympathy, and she theorized a gradual
historical progression in sympathy. Moving into the 1880s, Cobbe
combatted secularism, agnosticism, and atheism, arguing that
religion is necessary not only for morality but also for meaningful
life and culture. Shedding light on Cobbe's philosophical
perspective and its applications, this volume demonstrates the
range, systematicity and philosophical character of her work and
makes her core ethical theory and its central applications and
developments available for teaching and scholarship.
Conceptualism is the view that cognizers can have mental
representations of the world only if they possess the adequate
concepts by means of which they can specify what they represent. By
contrast, non-conceptualism is the view that mental representations
of the world do not necessarily presuppose concepts by means of
which the content of these representations can be specified, thus
cognizers can have mental representations of the world that are
non-conceptual. Consequently, if conceptualism is true then
non-conceptualism must be false, and vice versa. This
incompatibility makes the current debate over conceptualism and
non-conceptualism a fundamental controversy since the range of
conceptual capacities that cognizers have certainly has an impact
on their mental representations of the world, on how sense
perception is structured, and how external world beliefs are
justified. Conceptualists and non-conceptualists alike refer to
Kant as the major authoritative reference point from which they
start and develop their arguments. The appeal to Kant attempts to
pave the way for a robust answer to the question of whether or not
there is non-conceptual content. Since the incompatibility of the
conceptualist and non-conceptualist readings of Kant indicate a
paradigm case, hopes have risen that the answer to the question of
whether Kant is a conceptualist or a non-conceptualist might settle
the contemporary controversy across the board. This volume searches
for that answer. This book is based on a special issue of the
International Journal of Philosophical Studies.
The Perfection of Freedom seeks to respond to the impoverished
conventional notion of freedom through a recovery of an
understanding rich with possibilities yet all but forgotten in
contemporary thought. This understanding, developed in different
but complementary ways by the German thinkers Schiller, Schelling,
and Hegel, connects freedom, not exclusively with power and
possibility, but rather, most fundamentally, with completion,
wholeness, and actuality. What is unique here is specifically the
interpretation of freedom in terms of form, whether it be aesthetic
form (Schiller), organic form (Schelling), or social form (Hegel).
Although this book presents serious criticisms of the three
philosophers, it shows that they open new avenues for reflection on
the notion of freedom; avenues that promise to overcome many of the
dichotomies that continue to haunt contemporary thought - for
example, between freedom and order, freedom and nature, and self
and other. The Perfection of Freedom offers not only a
significantly new interpretation of Schiller, Schelling, and Hegel,
but also proposes a modernity more organically rooted in the
ancient and classical Christian worlds.
How did Nietzsche the philosopher come into being? The Nietzsche
known today did not develop 'naturally', through the gradual
maturation of some inborn character. Instead, from an early age he
engaged in a self-conscious campaign to follow his own guidance,
thereby cultivating the critical capacities and personal vision
which figure in his books. As a result, his published works are
steeped in values that he discovered long before he mobilised their
results. Indeed, one could argue that the first work which he
authored was not a book at all, but his own persona. Based on
scholarship previously available only in German, this book examines
Nietzsche's unstable childhood, his determination to advance
through self-formation, and the ways in which his environment,
notably the Prussian education system, alternately influenced and
impeded his efforts to find his own way. It will be essential
reading for all who are interested in Nietzsche.
Kant announces that the Critique of the Power of Judgment will
bring his entire critical enterprise to an end. But it is by no
means agreed upon that it in fact does so and, if it does, how. In
this book, Ido Geiger argues that a principal concern of the third
Critique is completing the account of the transcendental conditions
of empirical experience and knowledge. This includes both Kant's
analysis of natural beauty and his discussion of teleological
judgments of organisms and of nature generally. Geiger's original
reading of the third Critique shows that it forms a unified whole -
and that it does in fact deliver the final part of Kant's
transcendental undertaking. His book will be valuable to all who
are interested in Kant's theory of the aesthetic and conceptual
purposiveness of nature.
This book offers translations of early critical reactions to Kant's
account of free will. Spanning the years 1784-1800, the
translations make available, for the first time in English, works
by little-known thinkers including Pistorius, Ulrich, Heydenreich,
Creuzer and others, as well as familiar figures including Reinhold,
Fichte and Schelling. Together they are a testimony to the intense
debates surrounding the reception of Kant's account of free will in
the 1780s and 1790s, and throw into relief the controversies
concerning the coherence of Kant's concept of transcendental
freedom, the possibility of reconciling freedom with determinism,
the relation between free will and moral imputation, and other
arguments central to Kant's view. The volume also includes a
helpful introduction, a glossary of key terms and biographical
details of the critics, and will provide a valuable foundation for
further research on free will in post-Kantian philosophy.
David Hume is generally credited with the classic statement of the `compatibilist' position in the free will dispute. In this study it is argued that Hume's views on this subject, although largely influential, have nevertheless been seriously misrepresented. Classical readings have entirely overlooked Hume's naturalistic concerns and commitments, those very aspects of his general strategy which are of particular significance to the contemporary discussion. First study devoted entirely to Hume's influential views on freedom and responsibility. Gives historical context not only of Hume's laying foundation for a naturalistic approach to issues of moral sentiment and its relevance to problems of responsibility and free will, but also of Hume's anticipation of elements of contemporary discussion on these issues.
GWF Hegel has long been considered one of the most influential and
controversial thinkers of the nineteenth century, and his work
continues to provoke debate in contemporary philosophy. This new
book provides readers with an accessible introduction to Hegel's
thought, offering a lucid and highly readable account of his
"Phenomenology of Spirit," "Science of Logic," "Philosophy of
Nature," "Philosophy of History," and "Philosophy of Right." It
provides a cogent and careful analysis of Hegel's main arguments,
considers critical responses, evaluates competing interpretations,
and assesses the legacy of Hegel's work for philosophy in the
present day.In a comprehensive discussion of the major works, J.M
Fritzman considers crucial questions of authorial intent raised by
the "Phenomenology of Spirit," and discusses Hegel's conceptions of
necessity and of philosophical method. In his presentation of
Hegel's "Logic," Fritzman evaluates the claim that logic has no
presuppositions and examines whether this endorses a
foundationalist or coherentist epistemology. Fritzman goes on to
scrutinize Hegel's claims that history represents the progressive
realization of human freedom, and details how Hegel believes that
this is also expressed in art and religion. This book serves as
both an excellent introduction to Hegel's wide-ranging philosophy
for students, as well as an innovative critique which will
contribute to ongoing debates in the field.
Hegel's Transcendental Ontology argues that Hegel presents the
kernel of his metaphysics, in the Doctrine of the Concept, the
final part of his Science of Logic. The Concept has three moments:
universality (a process through which conceptual content of
empirical determinations is formed), particularity (a holistic
system of inferentially interrelated determinations comprising the
totality of conceptual content), and individuality (the totality of
objects conditioned by the shared system of empirical
determinations that comprise the particular moment). The book
details these three moments as well as the specific schema of their
relation to one another. One of its aims is to offer a resolution
to the recent debate between Kantian and traditional
metaphysics-based readings of Hegel that has been dominating Hegel
scholarship. The author claims that Hegel walked a narrow path
between Scylla, of offering just another version of the traditional
kind of metaphysics and Charybdis of abstaining from making any
substantive claims about the nature of reality and focusing
exclusively on the analysis of the faculty of understanding. Hegel
left behind traditional approaches to the problems of metaphysics
and, through a radical reformulation of the relationship between
thought and being, proposed a new kind of metaphysics that is
Kantian through and through.
Drawing on over a century of international Nietzschean scholarship,
this groundbreaking book discusses some of the unexplored
psychological reaches of Nietzsche's thought, as well as their
implications for psychotherapeutic practice. Nietzsche's philosophy
anticipated some of the most innovative cultural movements of the
last century, from expressionism and surrealism to psychoanalysis,
humanistic psychology and phenomenology. But his work on psychology
often remains discarded, despite its many insights. Addressing this
oversight, and in an age of managerialism and evidence-based
practice, this book helps to redefine psychotherapy as an
experiment that explores the limits and intricacies of human
experience. It builds the foundations for a differentialist
psychology: a life-affirming project that can deal squarely with
the challenges, joys and sorrows of being human. Nietzsche and
Psychotherapy will be of great interest to researchers interested
in the relationship between psychotherapy and philosophy,
Nietzschean scholars, as well as to clinicians grappling with the
challenges of working in the so-called "post-truth" age.
This work brings together, for the first time in English
translation, Hegel's journal publications from his years in
Heidelberg (1816 18), writings which have been previously either
untranslated or only partially translated into English. The
Heidelberg years marked Hegel's return to university teaching and
represented an important transition in his life and thought. The
translated texts include his important reassessment of the works of
the philosopher F. H. Jacobi, whose engagement with Spinozism,
especially, was of decisive significance for the philosophical
development of German Idealism. They also include his most
influential writing about contemporary political events, his essay
on the constitutional assembly in his native Wurttemberg, which was
written against the background of the dramatic political and social
changes occurring in post-Napoleonic Germany. The translators have
provided an introduction and notes that offer a scholarly
commentary on the philosophical and political background of Hegel's
Heidelberg writings.
Kant and Applied Ethics makes an important contribution to Kant
scholarship, illuminating the vital moral parameters of key ethical
debates. * Offers a critical analysis of Kant s ethics,
interrogating the theoretical bases of his theory and evaluating
their strengths and weaknesses * Examines the controversies
surrounding the most important ethical discussions taking place
today, including abortion, the death penalty, and same-sex marriage
* Joins innovative thinkers in contemporary Kantian scholarship,
including Christine Korsgaard, Allen Wood, and Barbara Herman, in
taking Kant s philosophy in new and interesting directions *
Clarifies Kant s legacy for applied ethics, helping us to
understand how these debates have been structured historically and
providing us with the philosophical tools to address them
In the decades after its publication, Goethe's Wilhelm Meister's
Apprenticeship served as a touchstone for such major philosophical
and literary figures as Schopenhauer, Schleiermacher, and Schlegel,
and was widely understood to be one of the greatest novels of the
German canon. But in the decades and centuries following, the
attention it has received in both disciplines has diminished in
comparison to either Goethe's Sorrows of Young Werther or his
Elective Affinities. This volume follows the impetus of its early
respondents to examine deeply what exactly Goethe's long and
complicated novel is doing, and how it engages with problems and
themes of human life. An interdisciplinary group of eminent
scholars grapple with the novel's engagement with central
philosophical questions such as individuality, development, and
authority; aesthetic formation and narrative (and human)
contingency; and gender, sexuality, and marriage. That these
questions and their working-through in Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre
are in tension with one another speaks ultimately to how literature
explores philosophical questions in ways that are open-ended,
creative, and contain potential for new and different solutions to
living with them. This unique philosophical approach to the form
and purpose of a literary masterpiece illuminates new inroads into
a novel at once famously complex and influential, and into the
projects of one Germany's greatest writers.
First published in 1818, The World as Will and Representation
contains Schopenhauer's entire philosophy, ranging through
epistemology, metaphysics, philosophy of mind and action,
aesthetics and philosophy of art, to ethics, the meaning of life
and the philosophy of religion, in an attempt to account for the
world in all its significant aspects. It gives a unique and
influential account of what is and is not of value in existence,
the striving and pain of the human condition and the possibility of
deliverance from it. This new translation of the first volume of
what later became a two-volume work reflects the eloquence and
power of Schopenhauer's prose and renders philosophical terms
accurately and consistently. It offers an introduction, glossary of
names and bibliography, and succinct editorial notes, including
notes on the revisions of the text which Schopenhauer made in 1844
and 1859.
|
|