|
|
Books > Science & Mathematics > Science: general issues > Philosophy of science
Today's "machine-learning" systems, trained by data, are so
effective that we've invited them to see and hear for us-and to
make decisions on our behalf. But alarm bells are ringing. Recent
years have seen an eruption of concern as the field of machine
learning advances. When the systems we attempt to teach will not,
in the end, do what we want or what we expect, ethical and
potentially existential risks emerge. Researchers call this the
alignment problem. Systems cull resumes until, years later, we
discover that they have inherent gender biases. Algorithms decide
bail and parole-and appear to assess Black and White defendants
differently. We can no longer assume that our mortgage application,
or even our medical tests, will be seen by human eyes. And as
autonomous vehicles share our streets, we are increasingly putting
our lives in their hands. The mathematical and computational models
driving these changes range in complexity from something that can
fit on a spreadsheet to a complex system that might credibly be
called "artificial intelligence." They are steadily replacing both
human judgment and explicitly programmed software. In best-selling
author Brian Christian's riveting account, we meet the alignment
problem's "first-responders," and learn their ambitious plan to
solve it before our hands are completely off the wheel. In a
masterful blend of history and on-the ground reporting, Christian
traces the explosive growth in the field of machine learning and
surveys its current, sprawling frontier. Readers encounter a
discipline finding its legs amid exhilarating and sometimes
terrifying progress. Whether they-and we-succeed or fail in solving
the alignment problem will be a defining human story. The Alignment
Problem offers an unflinching reckoning with humanity's biases and
blind spots, our own unstated assumptions and often contradictory
goals. A dazzlingly interdisciplinary work, it takes a hard look
not only at our technology but at our culture-and finds a story by
turns harrowing and hopeful.
In The Orce Man: Controversy, Media and Politics in Human Origins
Research, Miquel Carandell presents a thrilling story of a
controversy on an Spanish "First European" that involved
scientists, politicians and newspapers. In the early 1980s, with
Spanish democracy in its beginnings, the Orce bone was transformed
from a famous human ancestor to an apparently ridiculous donkey
remain. With a chronological narrative, this book is not centered
on whether the bone was human or not, but on the circumstances that
made a certain claim credible or not, from both the scientific
community and the general public. Carandell's analysis draws on the
thin line that separates success from failure and the role of media
and politics in the controversy.
Brian Skyrms presents eighteen essays which apply adaptive dynamics
(of cultural evolution and individual learning) to social theory.
Altruism, spite, fairness, trust, division of labor, and signaling
are treated from this perspective. Correlation is seen to be of
fundamental importance. Interactions with neighbors in space, on
static networks, and on co-evolving dynamics networks are
investigated. Spontaneous emergence of social structure and of
signaling systems are examined in the context of learning dynamics.
Nobel laureate Roald Hoffmann's contributions to chemistry are well
known. Less well known, however, is that over a career that spans
nearly fifty years, Hoffmann has thought and written extensively
about a wide variety of other topics, such as chemistry's
relationship to philosophy, literature, and the arts, including the
nature of chemical reasoning, the role of symbolism and writing in
science, and the relationship between art and craft and science. In
Roald Hoffmann on the Philosophy, Art, and Science of Chemistry,
Jeffrey Kovac and Michael Weisberg bring together twenty-eight of
Hoffmann's most important essays. Gathered here are Hoffmann's most
philosophically significant and interesting essays and lectures,
many of which are not widely accessible. In essays such as "Why Buy
That Theory," "Nearly Circular Reasoning," "How Should Chemists
Think," "The Metaphor, Unchained," "Art in Science," and "Molecular
Beauty," we find the mature reflections of one of America's leading
scientists. Organized under the general headings of Chemical
Reasoning and Explanation, Writing and Communicating, Art and
Science, Education, and Ethics, these stimulating essays provide
invaluable insight into the teaching and practice of science.
A discussion of the rapidly growing field, from a thinker at the
forefront of research at the interface of technology and the
humanities, this is a must-read for anyone interested in
contemporary developments in Continental philosophy and philosophy
of technology. Philosophy of technology regularly draws on key
thinkers in the Continental tradition, including Husserl,
Heidegger, and Foucault. Yet because of the problematic legacy of
the 'empirical turn', it often criticizes 'bad' continental
tendencies - lyricism, pessimism, and an outdated view of
technology as an autonomous, transcendental force. This
misconception is based on a faulty image of Continental thought,
and in addressing it Smith productively redefines our concept of
technology. By closely engaging key texts, and by examining
'exceptional technologies' such as imagined, failed, and impossible
technologies that fall outside philosophy of technology's current
focus, this book offers a practical guide to thinking about and
using continental philosophy and philosophy of technology. It
outlines and enacts three key characteristics of philosophy as
practiced in the continental tradition: close reading of the
history of philosophy; focus on critique; and openness to other
disciplinary fields. Smith deploys the concept of exceptional
technologies to provide a novel way of widening discussion in
philosophy of technology, navigating the relationship between
philosophy of technology and Continental philosophy; the history of
both these fields; the role of imagination in relation to
technologies; and the social function of technologies themselves.
The nature of matter and the idea of indivisible parts has
fascinated philosophers, historians, scientists and physicists from
antiquity to the present day. This collection covers the richness
of its history, starting with how the Ancient Greeks came to assume
the existence of atoms and concluding with contemporary
metaphysical debates about structure, time and reality. Focusing on
important moments in the history of human thought when the debate
about atomism was particularly flourishing and transformative for
the scientific and philosophical spirit of the time, this
collection covers: - The discovery of atomism in ancient philosophy
- Ancient non-Western, Arabic and late Medieval thought - The
Renaissance, when along with the re-discovery of ancient thought,
atomism became once again an important doctrine to be fully debated
- Logical atomism in early analytic philosophy, with Russell and
Wittgenstein - Atomism in Liberalism and Marxism - Atomism and the
philosophy of time - Atomism in contemporary metaphysics - Atomism
and the sciences Featuring 28 chapters by leading and younger
scholars, this valuable collection reveals the development of one
of philosophy's central doctrines across 2,500 years and within a
broad range of philosophical traditions.
Robert Boyle (1627-1691) believed that a reductionist conception of
the mechanical philosophy threatened the heuristic power and
autonomy of chemistry as an experimental science. While some
historical and philosophical scholars have examined his nuanced
position, understanding the chemical philosophy he developed
through his own experimental work is incredibly difficult even for
experts in the field. In The Chemical Philosophy of Robert Boyle,
Marina Paola Banchetti-Robino energetically explains Boyle's ideas
in a whole new light and proposes that Boyle regarded chemical
qualities as non-reducible dispositional and relational properties
that emerge from, and supervene upon, the mechanistic structure of
chymical atoms. Banchetti-Robino demonstrates that these ideas are
implicit in Boyle's writing, making his philosophical contributions
crucial to the fields of both philosophy and chemistry. The
arguments presented are further strengthened by a detailed
mereological analysis of Boylean chymical atoms as chemically
elementary entities, which establishes the theory of wholes and
parts that is most consistent with an emergentist conception of
chemical properties. More generally, this book examines the way in
which Boyle sought to accommodate his complex chemical philosophy
within the framework of the 17th century mechanistic theory of
matter. Banchetti-Robino conceptualizes Boyle's experimental work
as a scientific research programme, in the Lakatosian sense, to
better explain the positive and negative heuristic function of the
mechanistic theory of matter within his chemical philosophy. The
Chemical Philosophy of Robert Boyle actively engages with the
contemporary and lively debates over the nature of Boyle's ideas
about structural chemistry, fundamental mechanistic particles and
properties, the explanatory power of subordinate causes, the
complex relation between fundamental particles, natural kinds, and
unified chemical wholes. The book is a rich historical account that
begins with the dominant paradigms of 16th and 17th Century
chemical philosophy and takes readers all the way through to the
21st Century.
Probability is increasingly important for our understanding of the
world. What is probability? How do we model it, and how do we use
it? Timothy Childers presents a lively introduction to the
foundations of probability and to philosophical issues it raises.
He keeps technicalities to a minimum, and assumes no prior
knowledge of the subject. He explains the main interpretations of
probability-frequentist, propensity, classical, Bayesian, and
objective Bayesian-and uses stimulating examples to bring the
subject to life. All students of philosophy will benefit from an
understanding of probability, and this is the book to provide it.
Material objects persist through time and survive change. How do
they manage to do so? What are the underlying facts of persistence?
Do objects persist by being "wholly present" at all moments of time
at which they exist? Or do they persist by having distinct
"temporal segments" confined to the corresponding times? Are
objects three-dimensional entities extended in space, but not in
time? Or are they four-dimensional spacetime "worms"? These are
matters of intense debate, which is now driven by concerns about
two major issues in fundamental ontology: parthood and location. It
is in this context that broadly empirical considerations are
increasingly brought to bear on the debate about persistence.
Persistence and Spacetime pursues this empirically based approach
to the questions. Yuri Balashov begins by setting out major rival
views of persistence -- endurance, perdurance, and exdurance -- in
a spacetime framework and proceeds to investigate the implications
of Einstein's theory of relativity for the debate about
persistence. His overall conclusion -- that relativistic
considerations favour four-dimensionalism over three-dimensionalism
-- is hardly surprising. It is, however, anything but trivial.
Contrary to a common misconception, there is no straightforward
argument from relativity to four-dimensionalism. The issues
involved are complex, and the debate is closely entangled with a
number of other philosophical disputes, including those about the
nature and ontology of time, parts and wholes, material
constitution, causation and properties, and vagueness.
John Cottingham explores central areas of Descartes's rich and
wide-ranging philosophical system, including his accounts of
thought and language, of freedom and action, of our relationship to
the animal domain, and of human morality and the conduct of life.
He also examines ways in which his philosophy has been
misunderstood. The Cartesian mind-body dualism that is so often
attacked is only a part of Descartes's account of what it is to be
a thinking, sentient, human creature, and the way he makes the
division between the mental and the physical is considerably more
subtle, and philosophically more appealing, than is generally
assumed. Although Descartes is often considered to be one of the
heralds of our modern secular worldview, the 'new' philosophy which
he launched retains many links with the ideas of his predecessors,
not least in the all-pervasive role it assigns to God (something
that is ignored or downplayed by many modern readers); and the
character of the Cartesian outlook is multifaceted, sometimes
anticipating Enlightenment ideas of human autonomy and independent
scientific inquiry, but also sometimes harmonizing with more
traditional notions of human nature as created to find fulfilment
in harmony with its creator.
As a discipline, the philosophy of science is as old as philosophy
itself. Philosophy of Science: The Key Thinkers offers a
comprehensive historical overview of this fascinating field. Twelve
specially commissioned essays introduce and explore the
contributions of those philosophers who have shaped the subject and
the central issues and arguments therein. All the great
philosophers from Plato and Aristotle to the present day have been
philosophers of science. However, this book concentrates on modern
philosophy of science, starting in the nineteenth century and
offering coverage of all the leading thinkers in the field
including Whewell, Mill, Reichenbach, Carnap, Popper, Feyerabend,
Putnam, van Fraassen, Bloor, Latour, Hacking, Cartwright and many
more. Crucially the book demonstrates how the ideas and arguments
of these key thinkers have contributed to our understanding of such
central issues as experience and necessity, conventionalism,
logical empiricism, induction and falsification, the sociology of
science, and realism. Ideal for undergraduate students, the book
lays the necessary foundations for a complete and thorough
understanding of this fascinating subject.
This new edition of Thomas Kuhn's Revolution marks the 50th
anniversary of the publication of Kuhn's most influential work.
Drawing on the rich archival sources at MIT, and engaging fully
with current scholarship, James Marcum provides the historical
background to the development of The Structure of Scientific
Revolutions. Exploring the shift Kuhn makes from a historical to an
evolutionary philosophy of science and examining Kuhn's legacy in
depth, Marcum answers key questions: What exactly was Kuhn's
historiographic revolution and how did it come about? Why did it
have the impact it did? What will its future impact be for both
academia and society? Marcum's answers build a new portrait of
Kuhn: his personality, his pedagogical style and the intellectual
and social context in which he practiced his trade. Thomas Kuhn's
Revolution shows how Kuhn transcends the boundaries of the
philosophy of science, influencing sociologists, economists,
theologians and even policy makers and politicians. This is a
comprehensive historical and conceptual introduction to the man who
changed our understanding of science.
In recent decades, the analysis of causal relations has become a
topic of central importance in analytic philosophy. More recently,
dispositional properties have also become objects of intense study.
Both of these phenomena appear to be intimately related to
counterfactual conditionals and other modal phenomena such as
objective chance, but little work has been done to directly relate
them. Dispositions and Causes contains ten essays by scholars
working in both metaphysics and in philosophy of science, examining
the relation between dispositional and causal concepts.
Particular issues discussed include the possibility of reducing
dispositions to causes, and vice versa; the possibility of a
nominalist theory of causal powers; the attempt to reduce all
metaphysical necessity to dispositional properties; the
relationship between dispositions, causes, and laws of nature; the
role of causal capacities in explaining the success of scientific
inquiry; the grounding of dispositions and causes in objective
chances; and the type of causal power required for free agency.
The introductory chapter contains a detailed overview of recent
work in the area, providing a helpful entry to the literature for
non-specialists.
A distinguished scholar urges scientists and religious thinkers to
become colleagues rather than adversaries in areas where their
fields overlap Each age has its own crisis-our modern experience of
science-religion conflict is not so very different from that
experienced by our forebears, Keith Thomson proposes in this
thoughtful book. He considers the ideas and writings of Thomas
Jefferson and Charles Darwin, two men who struggled mightily to
reconcile their religion and their science, then looks to more
recent times when scientific challenges to religion (evolutionary
theory, for example) have given rise to powerful political
responses from religious believers. Today as in the eighteenth
century, there are pressing reasons for members on each side of the
religion-science debates to find common ground, Thomson contends.
No precedent exists for shaping a response to issues like cloning
or stem cell research, unheard of fifty years ago, and thus the
opportunity arises for all sides to cooperate in creating a new
ethics for the common good.
Gauge theories have provided our most successful representations of
the fundamental forces of nature. How, though, do such
representations work? Interpretations of gauge theory aim to answer
this question. Through understanding how a gauge theory's
representations work, we are able to say what kind of world our
gauge theories reveal to us.
A gauge theory's representations are mathematical structures.
These may be transformed among themselves while certain features
remain the same. Do the representations related by such a gauge
transformation merely offer alternative ways of representing the
very same situation? If so, then gauge symmetry is a purely formal
property since it reflects no corresponding symmetry in
nature.
Gauging What's Real describes the representations provided by
gauge theories in both classical and quantum physics. Richard
Healey defends the thesis that gauge transformations are purely
formal symmetries of almost all the classes of representations
provided by each of our theories of fundamental forces. He argues
that evidence for classical gauge theories of forces (other than
gravity) gives us reason to believe that loops rather than points
are the locations of fundamental properties. In addition to
exploring the prospects of extending this conclusion to the quantum
gauge theories of the Standard Model of elementary particle
physics, Healey assesses the difficulties faced by attempts to base
such ontological conclusions on the success of these theories.
It has long been thought that science is our best hope for
realizing objective knowledge, but that, to deliver on this
promise, it must be value free. Things are not so simple, however,
as recent work in science studies makes clear. The contributors to
this volume investigate where and how values are involved in
science, and examine the implications of this involvement for
ideals of objectivity.
|
|